Thirty-something pre-school teacher Sarah Nolan has been divorced for eight months, which is much too long for her co-workers and family to bear. With the best of intentions and only her happiness in mind, Sarah's sisters, Carol and Christine, begin lining up less-than-savory potential suitors. Meanwhile, their widowed father, Bill, is way ahead of the curve, having already cornered the market on internet dates, including his new web squeeze, the free-spirited Dolly. Eager to launch her sister's cyber-dating debut, Carol pretends to be Sarah, goes online and puts her profile on perfectmatch.com, with the last line being "Must love dogs." Sarah soon endures a torrent of eager wannabes and one very possible maybe, the handsome and accomplished but surprisingly awkward web date Jake as well as Bob, the newly-divorced dad of one of her students, a hot prospect who may prove too good to be true.